Why I gave up the right to advertise my own fund

When I set up my first fund, I did it for one reason. I wanted to create opportunities for our investors that they couldn’t get on their own.
What I did not have was any idea how to actually build one. I hired good people, I asked a lot of questions, and it still took the better part of a year. Revision after revision of the legal documents, each one clarifying something I hadn’t understood well enough to ask about the first time.
The decisions I ended up making were the right ones, and I’m proud of how they’ve held up. But I got there the expensive way, and the expensive part wasn’t the legal fees.
The gap nobody fills
Here’s what I’d do differently. Before I hired anybody, I’d have gone and talked to five operators who had already built one.
Your attorney tells you what’s permitted. That’s their job and mine did it well. What nobody tells you is what it’s like to live inside the structure for the next seven years, and that’s the part you can only get from somebody who’s living in one.
The difference sounds small until you’re in it. A lawyer will explain two options and their legal consequences, accurately. An operator will tell you which one made their life harder in year three, what they’d give up to have chosen differently, and which of those consequences turned out to matter and which never came up once.
I’m building another fund now, and I’m doing exactly that this time. I want the education to be part of what we hand people, because the part I paid the most for was the part nobody would have charged me for.
The first decision is who you’re allowed to talk to
Almost every private real estate deal you’ve ever seen was raised under Regulation D, which lets an offering skip SEC registration as long as it stays inside certain conditions. Rule 506 does nearly all the work, and it comes in two versions.
Under 506(b) you can’t advertise the raise. No posts about it, no cold outreach, no bought lists. You can only bring it to people you already had a real relationship with, where you understood their finances and their sophistication before the offering existed. In exchange, accredited status is usually established by the investor’s own signed questionnaire, and you’re allowed to include a limited number of non-accredited investors who are financially sophisticated.
Under 506(c) you can say anything you want out loud. Advertise, post, talk to strangers. The price is that every single investor has to be verified as accredited, with documents, and you have to take real steps to confirm it rather than take their word.
That’s the whole trade. One buys you reach. One buys you the ability to bring people in who would otherwise be shut out.
The investors I wasn’t willing to turn away
I picked 506(b), and I knew exactly what I was giving up when I did it.
Part of it was that I wanted to keep the first one close to home, with people I actually knew. But the bigger reason was the non-accredited piece. I had investors who had been with us for years, who understood what we do better than plenty of accredited people do, and who simply didn’t clear an income or net worth line written by somebody who had never met them. Under 506(c) I would have had to turn every one of them away.
I wasn’t willing to build something that only worked for the investors who needed it least. So I took the version that let them in, and I accepted that I couldn’t talk about the raise in public for as long as it was open.
That was the right call for that fund. It won’t be the right call forever, and I’ll say that plainly. Next time I’ll want to be able to talk about what we’re building out loud, and that means 506(c). Different fund, different goal, different trade.
Then COVID showed up
We went live and the world closed.
Nobody wanted to move money when nobody knew what the next six months looked like, and I don’t blame a single one of them. The raise got dramatically harder than anything I’d modeled.
So I did what an operator does. I raised the smallest amount I could to keep the fund alive, put it into a single asset, and waited until raising more made sense again. The structure I’d chosen is what gave me room to do that.
And through all of it I told our investors everything. We’ve held quarterly meetings since the very beginning, and our people have had information at their fingertips the entire time, in good stretches and in the stretch where I was explaining why we were slowing down on purpose. I believe that’s the single biggest reason this worked. I’m an open book, and I think every investor deserves to know exactly what’s happening with their dollars, especially when the answer isn’t the one they were hoping for.
If you’re thinking about building one
Go find operators before you find lawyers. Three or four people who have run a fund through a full cycle, not one who is raising right now and wants you excited about it. Ask them what they’d structure differently and why, and ask what they didn’t understand at the time. Most people will tell you, because most of us wish somebody had told us.
Then decide who you’re actually building this for, before anybody drafts anything. That single answer drives the exemption, the exemption drives how you’re allowed to raise, and how you raise shapes every relationship you’ll have for the life of the fund. It’s very hard to unwind later.
And whatever you choose, over-communicate from day one. Not when there’s news. On a schedule, whether there’s news or not. The habit is nearly free to start and almost impossible to install later, once people are already wondering why they haven’t heard from you.
I’m keeping notes on all of it as I build this one. If you’re structuring something now and want to compare notes with somebody a few years ahead of you on the same road, my calendar is here.
In my next Empire Brief, on November 12, I’ll get into depreciation and cost segregation, and the part of your return that never shows up in a distribution.









